Tagged: Ajahn Chah Toggle Comment Threads | Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Unknown's avatar

    hardie karges 5:26 pm on July 28, 2026 Permalink | Reply
    Tags: Ajahn Chah, Bangkok, Bhikku Pannakara, , , , , , Phra Piyathamoo, , Thonburi, Wat Nak Prok, Wat Pak Nam   

    Monks and Temples in Bangkok and Thonburi 

    Monks and Temples in Bangkok and Thonburi, part 1 

    Buddhism is strong in Thailand, and that means a lot, both there and elsewhere. Because it tends to shape society around it, and that can take many different forms. One of the changes that it has induced over the years is the introduction of a ‘Forest Temple’ Buddhism that has largely reinvigorated ancient Buddhism, and much for the better, I’d say. It’s hard to imagine that the long-distance-walking-for-peace tudong monks could have ever done what they have done without the prior introduction of Forest Temples to the country. Because, not only has it reinvigorated Buddhism in Thailand, but it has also spread to almost every other Theravada country, and the USA also, to the point that city temples might be seen as ‘institutional’ or corrupt, a problem which has often plagued Thailand, especially when rich kids ordain as monks for a week or two to avoid a lengthy prison sentence for assorted sins, ahem. 

    And that was largely my outlook when I spent two or three months in a Thai forest temple in 2016 before finally returning to college for my Buddhist Studies MA. But that judgment is not really fair and does a disservice to many fine monks and teachers across the spectrum of Thai society. Cities deserve monks, too, after all, now, don’t they? Of course they do. So, the choice is really an individual one and reflects many factors in the decision-making process, not the least of which is proximity, to family and friends and fellow members of the Buddhist sangha. Very few monks are the cave-dwellers of fable and legend. Still, some of the most dynamic teachers of the past century were indeed Forest Temple monks, including Ajahn Chah from the Northeast Isaan region of Thailand, who founded Thailand’s only International Forest Monastery near Ubon Ratchatani, which thrives to this day, and which uses the English language as the means of communication and instruction. Did I mention that Forest Temple monks are forbidden to carry money? 

    So, it felt somewhat unusual a month or so ago, when the Monks Walking for Peace held a weeklong conference in Thonburi, a large city suburb near Bangkok. And it was delightful, well-attended and well-connected. I quickly fell in love with both the temple and the entire neighborhood, which contains at least a healthy handful of temples, probably more. I’ll show five here, including the Wat Nang Prok, which I already showed last time during the Monks Walking for Peace conference in June. According to Wikipedia:  

    “The temple was presumably built in the year 1748 during the late Ayutthaya period. It is said that a wealthy Chinese merchant who lives in the neighboring Talat Phlu area named Phuk was the contributor of the temple’s building. The Vihāra (sanctuary) was in dedication to his Thai wife and the ubosot (ordination hall) was to himself. The Buddha image was later housed inside the vihāra and ubosot. The temple is named Wat Nak Prok after Luang Pho Nak Prok, the most sacred Buddha image made of bronze in Naga Prok attitude (under the shelter of a seven-headed Nāga) made of mortar housed inside the vihāra. The ubosot originally built in Ayutthaya period style is now being modified in accordance with the later restoration.” So, the Nahk of Nahk Prok is a seven-headed Naga monster. You heard it here first. There is also a beautiful and interesting Wat Nang Chee extremely close by and almost attached. Supposedly it is for nuns, but I so no one there after several visits, so I won’t comment on it. 

    But the temple closest to where I was staying was down a long country road in the middle of the big city and called Wat Nang Ratchaworawihan. On the other side of the khlong and almost back to the Wutthakat BTS stop, there’s another interesting temple called Wat Mai Yai Nui. BTW Temples are called wat. Canals are called khlong. Did I mention that this suburb actually pre-dates Bangkok and was once the capital of Siam before Bangkok was even a thing? Bangkok is actually called Krung Thep Mahanakorn (for short) by Thais, and canals are still an active means of transportation. Some things change slowly, and that’s what I like about Thonburi. So, the best thing about Wat Mai Yai Nui is that it’s right on the canal and boats load and unload passengers right then and there. That’s one of the nice things about a city temple. Don’t try that in the forest. The people, including monks, are friendly, too. But that’s pretty much the case everywhere.  

    Straight up the canal from there, Khlong Dan, is Wat Khun Chan, which is another delightful place, with stunning architecture, also from the Ayutthaya period, as most of the best of them are. But the standout temple of the neighborhood is directly across the canal and slightly on the way back to Wat Nak Prok. It is also one of the most controversial in Bangkok, Wat Pak Nam Bhasi Charoen. This is where all the nuns are, monks, too, hundreds of them, as well as a few lawsuits. Because this is a Dhammakaya temple, the original one, famous as much for its (supposed) money laundering as it is for its million-child-meditations which have been the stuff of Internet filler for years now, without many people really not knowing the back story. The leader was on the run for years, playing hide-and-seek with the law, while rich ‘friends’ (kalyanamitta) keep the new movement in the public eye as it seems set to replace the dominant Thai Buddhist sect Dhammayutika Nikaya with its own Maha Nikaya (‘nikaya’ means ‘discipline’ either as a common or proper noun). Their slogan is ‘World Peace through Inner Peace’. Sound familiar? 

    But I knew little or none of this the first time that I strolled blithely into the temple at the invitation of two nice older Thai ladies with whom I had just shared a bracelet session at Wat Nahk Prok with the celebrated hero of W4P Phra Piyathamoo. They were looking for something, but I can’t remember what it was. I know what I’m looking for, though. I just can’t find the words to express it. The main draw to Wat Paknam to the casual visitor, however, would likely be the huge statue of Buddha, which is visible from the distant highway and BTS elevated rail line which I use to reach this neighborhood from the distant airports, which seem almost light years away. Because this area is a world of its own, not just a product of the past, but a vision of the future to which we are headed. And I’m not too concerned about the politics of progress, as long as it is equitable and fair, any more than I am worried about the influence of money, as long as it is equitable and fair, also. I am only concerned that the tired old Buddhism of karma and rebirth give way to the new Buddhism of meditation and mindfulness. The Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Middle Path are still the same reliable foundation of it all.  

    But there is more to Thonburi than the beautiful Buddhist temples and the illustrious history. I’ll get to that in Part 2. If you liked Part 1, then please LIKE and subscribe, and please stay tuned for Part 2. Thank you. 

     
  • Unknown's avatar

    hardie karges 9:39 am on October 24, 2021 Permalink | Reply
    Tags: Ajahn Chah, , Buddhadasa, , , , ,   

    Buddhist Rebirth and the Oranges of Geronimo Bosch 

    Yes, we should keep an open mind about rebirth. We should also keep an open mind about no rebirth. Because the diehards are doubling down, in direct proportion to what they fear they have to lose, I suppose: certainty, predetermination, magic, or maybe even their jobs? But mostly, I think, they are worried about losing their religion, because religion is about nothing if not certainty, and without rebirth, Buddhism might be seen as lacking that, and so nothing more than a philosophy. But philosophy doesn’t pay the bills, and religion does, because that’s where you turn when times are hard, to magic and superstition, not existentialism or logical positivism.

    And let’s be clear that we’re not talking about ‘spiritual rebirth’ or being ‘born again’ in the Christian sense. Because, though the definition is deliberately fuzzy (how could it not be?), its resemblance to brother Hinduism’s reincarnation is hard to explain away. And in a sense it can serve as a stand-in for Christianity’s eternal life, even though the one is supposed to be a blessing and the other a curse. Often, I suppose that the curse you know is far preferable to the great unknown that is death.

    The religious quest that is certainty is often preferable to the scientific truth, which is tentative, by definition. And so, a big idea that was popular at the time, reincarnation and/or rebirth, was accepted by the Buddha, sorta kinda almost maybe, because it promised better results than the alternative. But it is now an obstacle for the evolving dharma which is Buddhism, and which is teetering on the side of dogma, if the ‘rebirthers’ get their way. And so far, up until now, they do get their way, as almost every time the Pali/Sanskrit word ‘jati’ is used, the correct translation as ‘birth’ is now retranslated as ‘rebirth.’ But there is a different word for that.

    Entire concepts, indeed, such as Dependent Origination, are remade in the image of rebirth. Ironically the monks who you’d think would be most resistant to this, the Westerners, are often in fact the ones doubling down. I spent a few months in a Thai forest temple, and we never talked about rebirth. Many Western monks talk about nothing else. One prominent Western monk has even declared that non-self ‘anatta’ was always tentative, so that there can be no issue over what gets reborn.

    In the Thai tradition, ‘making merit’ is a big deal and past lives are jokingly referred to, but the karma involved is little more than the Golden Rule, not the generation-jumping karma of retribution that characterizes the rebirth-heavy Tibetan tradition. And the revered Thai monk Buddhadasa specifically denied rebirth, while Ajahn Chah dodged the issue. Of course, my pet theory is that it’s all a ruse designed to ensure the dominance of the Brahmin caste in India over their lessers, but I can’t prove that—yet. Can it be proved that Christian eternal life is a pretext for capitalism? Probably not. This is the garden of earthly delights–enjoy, a little bit…

     
  • Unknown's avatar

    hardie karges 11:16 am on July 7, 2019 Permalink | Reply
    Tags: Ajahn Chah, , , , , ,   

    Buddhism, Mental Formations, and Defilements of the Heart and Logic… 

    Who says you can’t go home again? Home is a warm place in your heart, and mind. And if that’s a ‘mental formation’ as is often said in Buddhism, then that’s not such a bad one, but I’m not sure. I’ve studied Buddhism for several years now and I’m still not certain of the proper translation for the Pali/Sanskrit words sankhara/samskara that usually gets translated as the rather cryptic ‘mental formations’. But I do know that when Ajahn Chah, the great Thai forest master, used the term ‘arom’ อารมณ์ , which in normal speech means ‘feeling, emotion’, the translator rendered it as ‘mental formation’, so I figure that’s a valuable clue, notwithstanding the fact that the term may also have sexual connotations, depending on who says it, under what circumstances, and at what time of the day or night, in case you’re feeling sleepy. But that’s just the random white noise of mental idling, before or after an actual coherent thought, since I’m sure Ajahn Chah had no sexual connotation in mind, he one of the few post-Buddha (non)-personalities who I might credit with genuine Enlightenment. But feeling preceded linguistic thought, certainly, and I’ve heard Buddhist monks opine that ‘thought is a defilement’, so language falls flat, and that may be the point. In the beginning there was silence; and then there was noise. That’s all I know…

     
c
Compose new post
j
Next post/Next comment
k
Previous post/Previous comment
r
Reply
e
Edit
o
Show/Hide comments
t
Go to top
l
Go to login
h
Show/Hide help
shift + esc
Cancel